Yogurt Homemade Vs Store Bought
~ Some Differences ~

This page explains the difference in appearance in yogurt... homemade may not look exactly like store bought.  Before you start wondering if you made it right, read this through.  Your curd most likely turned out the way it was supposed to...

You're just seeing it in a completely natural state.  Not in a packaged container. And with thickeners, colors and fruit added.  Once you stir in fruit or berries, especially ones that add some color, it'll look more familiar.

Yogurt Homemade

Home Made Yogurt

There can be differences in thickness (and taste) depending on:

  • type and amount of culture
  • type of milk
  • length of incubation

Culture, milk and incubation can all be adjusted, with experimentation, to suit your taste.  Curd can be made thicker or thinner, stronger or milder tasting.

Aside from that, it's natural for some liquid, called whey, to separate from the curd. Don't be hasty to throw it out..... there are ways to use the whey :).  Whey is high in protein and can be be used in place of milk or water in soups, gravies, sauces and baking.

If you haven't added thickeners don't be surprised to have whey separate from the solids.

Homemade Curds and Whey

Here's how you can expect plain homemade yoghurt to look before stirring, straining or adding other ingredients......and after stirring.

Notice the whey in the bowl on the left.  This particular batch of yogurt wasn't thickened and the milk wasn't heat treated before inoculating.  The longer yogurt rests the more wheying off occurs.

Store Bought Yogurt

Commercial yoghurt comes in two varieties, made using different processes:

  1. Set - includes plain, sundae style or fruit-on-the-bottom, western style
  2. Stirred or Swiss style, special Swiss style

Both can have gelatin and other thickeners added but they're most commonly used in stirred yogurt. You can make thicker or firmer yogurt homemade without adding gelatin.

Set Yoghurt

Fruit Bottom Yoghurt

Is made in a similar manner to homemade, just on a commercial scale.  Most, if not all, of the plain yogurt sold at the store is set.  When you open the container or after you've used some of it, you might find liquid sitting on top.  This is whey that's separated from the curd.  Generally quality yogurt without additives will have some whey separation.

Another set yogurt you may have bought is sundae (fruit-on-the-bottom) or western style.  Sundae style is made by adding fruit or preserves to the bottom of the container, then adding the inoculated milk and incubated. 

I've made fruit-on-the-bottom at home and it's very good.  The texture, appearance and taste are similar to store bought.  Western style has a layer of fruit on the bottom and a flavored and colored yogurt on top.  You could make this yogurt homemade too if you wished.

Stirred or Swiss Style Yoghurt

Swiss Style Yoghurt

Chances are if you buy sweetened or flavored yogurt at the store, it's stirred.  It has the consistency of pudding.  When stirred yogurt is manufactured the inoculated milk to allowed to set (become yogurt).  Then it's stirred and the flavoring and coloring are added.  The fruit, flavor and color are mixed along with gelatin or some other thickener to make it coagulate again.  The mixture is poured into containers where it "sets" a second time.

If you're really fond of this type of yoghurt you could try it yourself at home.  I don't see any reason why it wouldn't turn out.  My preference is to make natural set yogurt and add the flavoring after.

Mixed Berries
Yogurt Homemade
Fresh Berries

Stay Cultured! with new recipes and beauty tips using cultured dairy products.  Sign up to receive the monthly Stay Cultured! newsletter.

Enter Your E-mail Address
Enter Your First Name

Don't worry — your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you Stay Cultured!.

I need your feedback.  Thanks for taking 1 minute to answer these 3 questions

What Will Help You Make Yogurt?

powdered yogurt culture handy in cupboard
starter kit (culture, thermometer, mason jar)
audio (mp3) instructions
video on how to make yogurt
all of the above
no yogurt culture
no milk
no thermometer
no way to incubate
afraid yogurt won't turn out
no time
all of the above
under 18
18 to 29
30 to 39
40 to 49
50 to 59
60 to 69
over 70

Please enter the word that you see below.


Fresh Berries

top of page

Family Friendly Site Logo

What Do YOU Need To Culture Dairy?

Recent Articles

  1. Buttermilk Cornbread Recipe

    Jan 10, 15 09:19 AM

    This moist, gluten free Buttermilk Cornbread recipe is delicious. Make it unique by adding cheese, corn, and spices - Paraguayan style.

    Read More

  2. Homemade Yogurt Recipes: Delectably Flavored

    Apr 03, 14 09:23 AM

    Homemade Yogurt Recipes: Sweeteners, jams, cooked fruits, flavors and spices can be added to milk before incubation. Recipes to make delicous strawberry, chocolate, mocha curd and more.

    Read More

  3. Strawberry Frozen Yogurt Recipe

    Mar 03, 14 01:52 PM

    This Lite Strawberry Frozen Yogurt Recipe is bursting with the delectable flavor of strawberries. Low in calories and fat... a dieter's delight. So smooth and creamy you'd never guess.

    Read More

Stay Cultured!

Sign up to receive a "cultured" recipe or beauty tip once a month.

Enter Your E-mail Address
Enter Your First Name

Don't worry — your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you Stay Cultured!.

Top Quality Ingredients Equals Top Quality Yogurt.   You'll find the best priced organic and quality ingredients are at this store.  A few I use are:

Here's an easy $10 to get you started. Click on any of the products (above) or this store link.  A $10 discount  will automatically be put in your cart (for new customers).

[?]Subscribe To Blog
  • follow us in feedly
  • Add to My Yahoo!
  • Add to My MSN
  • Subscribe with Bloglines